Rotten Tomatoes
Cancel Movies Tv shows

Scott Tobias

Tomatometer-approved critic
Biography:

I see movies, watch DVDs, and read books, then I get paid to write what I think of them. Beats doing stuff.

Favorites:

Top 5 (no order): Sansho The Bailiff, Duck Soup, Tokyo Story, Shoot The Piano Player, Taxi Driver

Critics' Group:
Location:

Chicago

Reviews

Movies 온라인카지노추천 Shows
American Psycho (2000) 68% “As Bateman, Bale exudes just the right kind of anti-charisma.” – Guardian Apr 2, 2025 Full Review There Was, There Was Not (2024) 100% 4/5 “There Was, There Was Not becomes a wrenching memorial for a country that no longer exists, a fairy tale without a happily ever after. ” – The Reveal (Substack) Nov 1, 2024 Full Review Sasquatch Sunset (2024) 72% 3.5/5 “There’s a slightness to the conceit of Sasquatch Sunset that the Zellners cannot quite overcome, but there’s a generosity to the comedy and to its appreciation of the natural world that’s hard to resist. ” – The Reveal (Substack) Apr 17, 2024 Full Review R.M.N. (2022) 97% 3.5/5 “Though Mungiu takes a heavy hand with the symbolism, particularly in a head-scratcher of a final moment, his main characters remain irreducible in the face of a conflict that’s seemingly cut-and-dried. ” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 6, 2023 Full Review Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore (1974) 92% “Alice's story of female independence and self-realization inspired an awful sitcom, but Scorsese and star Ellen Burstyn give the film an edgy, foul-mouthed toughness that's resolutely unfit for television. ” – AV Club Oct 11, 2023 Full Review Y tu mamá también (2001) 90% “There are plenty of boys-to-men films about the raunchy adventures of pleasure-seeking teenagers, but Alfonso Cuarón's inspired and exhilarating road movie... taps so directly into their teeming energy that it all but levitates off the screen.” – AV Club Sep 9, 2023 Full Review Traffic (2000) 93% “Traffic could have been a bland, documentary-like procedural, but he gives it the distinctive two-tone look he brought to Out Of Sight, an eerily effective ambient soundtrack, and frequently radical editing rhythms.” – AV Club Aug 9, 2023 Full Review Mulholland Dr. (2001) 84% “Mulholland Drive gives way to an internal dream logic that can only be described as Lynchian. ” – AV Club Jul 10, 2023 Full Review Fast X (2023) 57% 3/5 “Fast X has enough joyful self-awareness that resistance becomes futile. At a certain point, it feels better to give in and smile.” – Guardian May 17, 2023 Full Review Heavenly Creatures (1994) 95% “Heavenly Creatures careens toward tragedy in a breathtaking rush, with every swoop of the camera whooshing the audience closer to the inevitable. ” – AV Club May 15, 2023 Full Review Come and See (1985) 89% “A product of the glasnost era, Come And See is far from a patriotic memorial of Russia's hard-won victory. Instead, it's a chilling reminder of that victory's terrible costs.” – AV Club Mar 14, 2023 Full Review Down in the Delta (1998) 76% “Though well-intentioned and occasionally affecting, Down In The Delta is more successful as a social tool than a work of art. ” – AV Club Jan 4, 2023 Full Review Smile (2022) 79% 3.5/5 “Finn uses the strength of his conceit to turn the screws, raising tension through the Ring-like timeline Rose faces and the sheer relentlessness of her supernatural tormentor.” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 19, 2022 Full Review Triangle of Sadness (2022) 72% 4/5 “Triangle of Sadness doesn’t leave audiences with much to unpack thematically, but it’s clear-eyed and hilarious about the systems that enforce societal inequities and what might happen if they were ever to unravel.” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 19, 2022 Full Review Decision to Leave (2022) 94% 4/5 “It’s not as immediately gripping as his previous work, but it lingers like perfume.” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 19, 2022 Full Review Tár (2022) 91% 4.5/5 “Burrows itself so deeply into a single character’s perspective that it defies all generalization or facile politicking. ” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 19, 2022 Full Review Ticket to Paradise (2022) 57% 2.5/5 “The gnawing arbitrariness of Ticket to Paradise cuts to the heart of why the Hollywood rom-com has been so deficient for so long, often turning to outrageously silly premises just to throw some obstacles in the way.” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 19, 2022 Full Review The Good Nurse (2022) 74% 3.5/5 “A sobering thriller that’s ostensibly about a serial killer, but more concerned about the healthcare system that allowed him to operate for 15 years before he was finally brought to justice.” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 19, 2022 Full Review Descendant (2022) 100% 4/5 “Has the self-awareness not merely to put Black voices at the center, where they belong, but to underline those moments when white people step up and intervene in the situation—sometimes as allies and advocates, sometimes to stake their own claim.” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 19, 2022 Full Review Weird: The Al Yankovic Story (2022) 84% 2.5/5 “A goofy made-up plot about Al’s relationship with Madonna (Evan Rachel Wood) sends the film off on an unfunny tangent from which it never returns. ” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 19, 2022 Full Review Armageddon Time (2022) 76% 4/5 “Armageddon Time is the rare case where the bitterness overwhelms sweetness, and true enlightenment comes from rejecting nostalgia at every turn.” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 19, 2022 Full Review The Menu (2022) 88% 3.5/5 “The film fares better as a tightly constructed exercise in horror, like a cross between the mechanized death of a Saw movie and the eat-the-rich grotesquerie of Peter Greenaway’s The Cook, the Thief, His Wife & Her Lover. ” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 19, 2022 Full Review The Fabelmans (2022) 92% 4/5 “Writing with Tony Kushner, who brought so much dimension to the familiar stories of Lincoln and West Side Story, Spielberg turns The Fabelmans into an act of self-mythology that nonetheless picks at old scabs. ” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 19, 2022 Full Review All the Beauty and the Bloodshed (2022) 95% 4.5/5 “All the Beauty and the Bloodshed encapsulates the love and tragedy that has affected Goldin’s life without coarsening it.” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 19, 2022 Full Review The Whale (2022) 64% 2.5/5 “Most of the conflicts in The Whale are overcooked nonsense, contrived for dramatic impact but divorced from any recognizable reality. ” – The Reveal (Substack) Dec 19, 2022 Full Review
No Reviews Yet
Load More