It's a fine adaptation that should appeal to fans and no one else.

The first one holds the record

I got this movie for a birthday one year as a kid. It was not a happy birthday when I watched this. But thanks for the gift, mom! :D

Nice family movie and interesting conclusion to this trilogy of the lovable dog and the family around him

Cute story line, but not that great of graphics and acting.

Better than the first. But a little slow. GRADE:A-

This was a very good movie but really sad

a good movie for dog lovers of all ages

Saving Shiloh is a very good family movie. I just wish it hadn't strayed so far away from what made the first one better. I hated in this one how the focus was almost completely taken off Shiloh and that he was barely in the movie and when he was he was subjected to the background. I didn't like how he was very much of a factor except near the end. I also didn't like how the story felt a little convoluted and couldn't decide on what story it wanted to tell. As for the positives, the movie actually had a decent mystery to it and I enjoyed the ending and felt it was quite heartwarming.

j'aime trop jason dans ce film c'est le seul film que je l'aime !

I don't think that I would have let my kids wonder around like that. (January 15, 2011)

Great movie!! My favorite out of the series. To many changes in the acting like the father and all was diffrent but hey a great movie to end the fantastic series, hope they come to a conclusion to make Shiloh 4.

This is a mediocre family film with nothing too much wrong with it, or right with it, until the paint-by-numbers ending, which is atrociously predictable. How did it get on my list? This is a mystery that is far more captivating than this film.

saw at school good moive

Hey it was 4am nothing else was on,anyway kinda corny,it was a little bit slow,boring for me but it was cute

Sweet movie for kids, the book was also very good.

best movie in the wolrd

Predictable children's movie. I only watched it 'cos the wife bought the DVD to lend to her kids at school. Pleasant enough, but not my cup of tea.

I was wondering when they will make the last one. I liked it. It was a great movie.

some of the worse acting by kids..I found myself laughing towards the end of this crap