Rotten Tomatoes
Cancel Movies Tv shows
Critics list

Sarah Musnicky

Tomatometer-approved critic
Biography:

Sarah Musnicky has been a freelance critic and film journalist since 2016. Since starting at Legion of Leia, she has written and provided content for ComingSoon, Vital Thrills, and But Why Tho? A Geek Community. She recently concluded her run as EIC of horror outlet Nightmarish Conjurings. When she’s not watching screeners with her cat, Jupiter, she is busying herself learning the art of creative fiction and trying to consume the world’s supply of coffee.

Reviews

Movies 온라인카지노추천 Shows
The Legend of Ochi (2025) 80% 7/10 “Even if the story itself could have used a bit of work, The Legend of Ochi is an excellent tableau, cluing us into the mind and ingenuity of first-time feature-filmmaker Isaiah Saxon. ” – VitalThrills.com Apr 18, 2025 Full Review Marshmallow (2025) 8/10 “Marshmallow is a surprising gateway horror with a twist that adds some creativity and fun in familiar territory. This is a showcase not just for DelPurgatorio and Greskoviak but also for its incredibly talented cast.” – InBetweenDrafts Apr 11, 2025 Full Review Revelations (2025) 68% 6/10 “Yeon Sang-ho’s Revelations (2025) is, by and large, an okay film. Much of the film’s heavy lifting is delivered by its performances and visuals,” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Mar 21, 2025 Full Review Control Freak (2025) 64% 6/10 “Despite its emphasis on control, Control Freak loses it by juggling different variables. Not all of them make it, with some story moments crashing onto the floor...[.] With that, the potential for something great is there.” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Mar 10, 2025 Full Review The Ugly Stepsister (2025) 96% 9.5/10 “It is painful and tear-jerking and another reminder of how societal beauty standards and our quest to achieve them cause more harm than good. As Blichfeldt has said, we are all stepsisters, and through Elvira's journey, we have been warned. ” – Creepy Kingdom Jan 28, 2025 Full Review Companion (2025) 93% 6/10 “Companion boasts many twists and turns, with entertaining and hilarious moments that will make audiences chuckle. But look deeper, and the cracks become glaringly visible, removing some of the shine from what could have been a more satisfying feature.” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Jan 23, 2025 Full Review Devils Stay (2024) “DEVILS STAY is an underwhelming, bloated affair. Despite its more intriguing components, too many elements distract within its story.” – Creepy Kingdom Jan 3, 2025 Full Review That Christmas (2024) 67% 6.5/10 “That Christmas may not be the most revolutionary holiday film, but there’s enough heart, silliness, and prime messaging in this animated film to give it its wings.” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Dec 4, 2024 Full Review The Snow Sister (2024) 7.5/10 “With its lulling, slower pace and subject matter, The Snow Sister might not be the holiday movie families want to add to their list. However, it is refreshing in its embrace of the haunting traits of more somber traditional Christmas storytelling.” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Nov 29, 2024 Full Review Our Little Secret (2024) 37% 8/10 “Lindsay Lohan and Ian Harding are a match made in rom-com heaven, from which not even Kristin Chenoweth’s terrifyingly accurate matriarch can steal the thunder.” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Nov 27, 2024 Full Review The Merry Gentlemen (2024) 41% 6.5/10 “The extra special flair of having an all-male dance revue come to save the day is a lovely touch that works to bring in viewers but also reminds us that creativity can and will save the day.” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Nov 20, 2024 Full Review Hot Frosty (2024) 74% 6/10 “Hot Frosty is ultimately a silly, fun time. The premise of a snowman coming to life as a flesh and blood man and engaging in shenanigans around town lends itself to that, and therein lies its strength. ” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Nov 13, 2024 Full Review The Best Christmas Pageant Ever (2024) 92% 8/10 “Despite its minor issues, The Best Christmas Pageant Ever encapsulates the book’s spirit, evoking the timelessness of Barbara Robinson’s messaging. If there is a new Christmas film to watch with the family this year, this one is it.” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Nov 11, 2024 Full Review Meet Me Next Christmas (2024) 69% 7.5/10 “While the plot is pretty standard, Meet Me Next Christmas stands out with how kinetic Christina Milian and Devale Ellis are.” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Nov 6, 2024 Full Review Tokyo Uber Blues (2021) 8/10 “Taku Aoyagi turned his life experience during the pandemic into relatable gold in Tokyo Uber Blues. ” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Oct 21, 2024 Full Review Love Stuck (2024) 6.5/10 “Love Stuck honors the original film at its core, maintaining the magically impactful lessons and overwhelming heart its predecessor carried.” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Oct 18, 2024 Full Review The Platform 2 (2024) 35% 4/10 “The Platform 2 fails to ascend past its predecessor, retreading familiar territory and forgoing the benefits of delicious ambiguity for heavy-handed exposition.” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Oct 6, 2024 Full Review Hold Your Breath (2024) 40% 2.5/5 “As an examination of tragic madness, HOLD YOUR BREATH almost gets it. But it gets lost in the dust it hopes to use for scares.” – Creepy Kingdom Oct 2, 2024 Full Review The Assessment (2024) 82% 8.5/10 “The Assessment is equally chaotic and devastating, capturing the nuanced complexities of parenthood with topical questions that many have found themselves asking on their own journey.” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Sep 28, 2024 Full Review Harbin (2024) 88% 6.5/10 “Woo Min-ho’s prioritizing of the plot over its characters leaves this inspiring, tension-driven tale feeling a little hollow. And that’s a dang shame because, without taking that into account, Harbin is a competent, thrilling film.” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Sep 23, 2024 Full Review Apartment 7A (2024) 43% 5/10 “The theatricality alone gives APARTMENT 7A a different look and feel that separates it from its predecessor, but it's arguably not enough. Rosemary's Baby's beating heart echoes throughout, with the story doing little to go beyond the confines of ritual.” – Creepy Kingdom Sep 21, 2024 Full Review Never Let Go (2024) 58% 6.5/10 “Capturing the atmosphere and ambiguity of a Southern gothic fairytale, this film is rooted in place by the strength of its performances. Through the relationships captured onscreen, some storytelling sins are forgiven.” – Creepy Kingdom Sep 20, 2024 Full Review The Substance (2024) 89% 4/5 “THE SUBSTANCE never shies away from its non-subtle, expressive view of how we process aging. It is brutally honest in its rage, internalized and externalized, but also in Sparkles' self-discovery, there's something akin to hope.” – Creepy Kingdom Sep 18, 2024 Full Review Shell (2024) 47% 4/10 “While the film might have been a risk for Minghella, Shell fails to take any until its climax. Too timid to align with a tone and commit, the film dances around, squandering its opportunity for anything significant to explore the topics it’s dealing with ” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Sep 15, 2024 Full Review K-Pops (2024) 87% 6.5/10 “K-Pops! is a sweet film, if generally formulaic, that has a lot of heart” – But Why Tho? A Geek Community Sep 14, 2024 Full Review
No Reviews Yet
Load More