Well written and acted! Spoilers ahead: Someone wrote a review saying the writers were making the girl her own grandma. If you paid attention, you’d know that’s not the case. Ellie’s mother was not Anna’s mother, she was her step mother. Anna was Daniel’s daughter only. Ellie and Anna were step sisters and Anna also was Ellie’s grandmother thanks to the twist. Great movie! Give me more.

**3.5/5 Stars – “Caddo Lake” Is a Mysterious Ride Worth Taking** Always down for anything with Dylan O’Brien, and *Caddo Lake* delivers—slowly, but surely. It starts off as your standard small-town thriller: eerie, emotional, with just enough drama to keep you leaning in. The first half is pure mystery slowburn, but halfway through, bam—sci-fi enters the chat, and I *loved* it. Totally caught me off guard in the best way. There’s a killer plot twist that flips everything you thought you knew, and I’m a sucker for that. Acting? Great. Vibes? Suspenseful and haunting. Execution? Solid, though not perfect—I just wish they explained more about the time shifts. That one dangling question kinda nags at you. But still, it’s the kind of film you think about afterward, which says a lot. If you like mystery with a side of the unexpected, give this one a go. Bonus points if you’re a Dylan fan.

This was wooooow! It was so complex. Like it reminded me of FROM, and the only reason people gave low stars is mainly because they didn't get the plot. In order to get the plot, you can't miss details. There was no loop holes...everything made sense. You just have to pay close attention or you will get confused for missing the slightest thing. It was fascinating and amazing experience for me. Won't give no spoilers, just watch the movie please.

Love the acting and plot twists.

Caddo Lake was so much more than I thought it would be, a rly fun movie

The performances are pretty solid, but the plot is too muddy and there is some odd looking CGI-ish type imagery which looked "off".

Definitely a good watch if you're looking for a psychological drama to take up your spare time. Very confusing during the watch but it all makes sense in the end.

Mindfuck of the century!!!! I've only begun to understand it, and it's been over 2 hours in intense discussion with the others of my group who watched it with me. Yes, good luck, and HOLD ON for the ride of your life!

Didn't get it, didn't want to get it. Tired of time travel, time loops. Good acting.

While it's not top notch, it is pretty cool. It could be better, but it had my attention the whole time and that counts for something. I had no expectations and that may have helped my view on this, but I think there's a cool plot and some surprising aha moments along the way.

Caddo Lake. Caddo Lake is one of those rare films that quietly slipped under the radar, lacking the usual fanfare associated with an M. Night Shyamalan project. While Trap received overwhelming media coverage despite being one of his weaker films, Caddo Lake went largely unnoticed—a real shame, considering how well-crafted and engaging it is. At its core, Caddo Lake is a mind-bending thriller that rewards patience. It started off slow for me but it carefully built up its mystery, never to the point of dullness. I was never bored or disengaged. As the story unfolds, seemingly disconnected pieces begin to click into place, culminating in a deeply satisfying moment of realisation. This structured reveal—almost like a simulated epiphany—demonstrates smart writing and a narrative that respects its viewers' intelligence. Dylan’s performance is particularly strong, anchoring the film with emotional weight, and the entire cast delivers solid work. While not a horror film in the traditional sense, Caddo Lake thrives on eerie tension and a sense of unease, leaning more into psychological thrills than outright scares. The cinematography is another standout, with breathtaking visuals that deserved a big-screen debut rather than a quiet streaming release. Fans of the German series Dark will likely find familiar elements here—complex storytelling, layered mysteries, and a nonlinear approach to time and memory. While Caddo Lake doesn’t feel derivative, it does share that intricate, thought-provoking style, requiring viewers to actively engage rather than passively watch. Some aspects may seem cryptic or even implausible at first glance, but that’s part of its charm—this is a film that invites discussion, analysis, and repeat viewings. One of its most intriguing aspects is its refusal to tie everything up neatly. Instead of providing easy answers, Caddo Lake embraces ambiguity, leaving certain threads open-ended and inviting the audience to interpret its meaning. It’s a bold move that may frustrate some but ultimately sets it apart from more conventional thrillers. This is a film that rewards careful watching, listening, and connecting with its characters. Every detail contributes to its final impact, making for a deeply immersive experience. While it’s disappointing that Caddo Lake hasn’t received the recognition it deserves, it’s definitely one I’ll be recommending to others. Watching everything come together was a shock in the best way possible, and I hope more people give it a chance. 8/10

My mind is going to be trying to piece thru this for a while.

An amazing mindfuck. Constant mindblowing met information with an amazing end! Don't watch the trailer for even more fun!

Made my head hurt like crazy. I was waiting for the most odd hand-fed twist of my life and realized that was never going to happen. My brain got twisted and now it is in pain.

A bit slow to begin with but was absolutely amazing! The story & plot I think was very intriguing & kept me interested enough to keep watching but as I kept watching, the more things that happened that really didn't make sense started making sense. I loved that OMG, I get it now feeling and this movie did amazing in delivering that. Definitely worth the watch. I was talking about it for a few weeks after!

Definitely a unique watch that makes you think. The story itself could've developed a bit deeper but the overall concept was good. As a limited series this could've been an absolute hit.

Absolutely amazingly filmed movie uses the backwaters as a setting for intricate horror

Suspend your disbelief and enjoy this absorbing mystery.

Tense and clever, a riveting watch from the beginning which all comes to a climactic end which leaves you with an array of emotions. Best film I’ve watched in a long time!

This is absolutely my favorite genre of film. There are great references to mystery series here, and if you love the genre, you'll be in for a treat with Caddo Lake. Here, the less you know before watching, the BETTER! It's smart and fun to slowly unravel the mysteries, but if you've already watched "Dark", some of them will be easier to solve. Still, it's all very well constructed, even for a streaming-only film with a tight budget. The main characters give great performances, and the secondary characters' plots don't distract from the central plot, adding interesting layers to the surprises and twists. I had a fantastic experience with this film and highly recommend it!