Convincing performances by Bardem. But the film itself was not for me and couldn't get it.

With the names attached to Before Night Falls, things fall into place about how you'd expect - Julian Schnabel directs an imaginative biography about a nonfiction protagonist going through some form of suffering and/or repression, and Javier Bardem gives a more than capable leading performance that allows you to gloss over some of the faults. Bardem takes on the Cuban writer Reinaldo Arenas, whose homosexuality and political criticism frequently caused his work to be suppressed by the Castro regime. The film tackles episodes in his life with apparent accuracy and picks apart some fascinating individual scenes - the gay scene in Revolutionary Cuba, a residency in a collapsing cathedral constructing a hot air balloon to fly to the United States, and a tenure as a prison writer smuggling portions of his novel out through Johnny Depp's butt. But the film seems to tiptoe around dissecting Arenas as a character, and his actual literary output is almost completely ignored; you don't step away feeling that you know more about the nonfiction subject except for the fact that he was persecuted. The acting is very good, Bardem never wavers in his capability and a near-unrecognizable Depp plays both a handsome police officer and a prisoner in glamorous drag (it's an unorthodox role that almost never gets brought up given Depp's fame). But Arenas simply suffers in Cuba, then simply suffers from AIDS somewhere else; early hints at Arenas the author seem much more distinctive than Arenas the victim. For a film about a Cuban writer that takes place almost entirely in Cuba, a surprising amount of this film is in English. But there seems to be something of a point to that, as most of the Cuban scenes include dialogue in English, while that alternates to Spanish once Arenas escapes to New York; the language may come across as inauthentic in some places, but it's used as an indication of the protagonist's outcast nature, no matter where he goes. (3/5)

While at times fleetingly fascinating, this work overwhelms itself with cinematic styles that intertwine into a vaguely incoherent, artistic ‘splash ‘n drip' type exercise. Director Julian Schnabel's intercutting of imagined events into the general story flow, often doesn't run smoothly as it should. If anything, the musical aspects of the production offer more interest than its variable visual styles, with composer Carter Burwell contributing considerable moodiness to several sequences. The homosexuality on display here is more the selfish-gratification type than the ‘relationship' variety. And with the Bi-sexual aspect being highlighted, it's little wonder sexual diseases proliferated in this society. Those who use their pro-creational organ in a ‘sewer' (so to speak) as regularly as these, invite serious risk factors. Added to this, the un-naturally high number of male ‘partners' Reinaldo Arenas boasted, virtually assured his sad and painful demise. Now, we also have the added threat of Monkeypox, credited as being born and spread within these lifestyles. The historical study of the introduction of Socialism into Cuban society and its impacts as displayed within this story - tends to confirm what many only learn after inviting this ominous system into its governing powers. While elements of the basic story often come across as somewhat fanciful, the cast does justice to the situations (some harrowing) within these flamboyant, risqué circles. This will be a film of limited interest to mainstream viewers (as the box office returns confirm) and may offer little enjoyment.

Julian Schnabel's Before Night Falls is the story of Cuban writer Reinaldo Arenas, from early childhood to death, during the time of the Cuban Revolution. Initially enamored by the rebels and the deposing of President Batista, Castro's regime ultimately set their sites on the art community and homosexuals, causing Arenas to re-evaluate his principles. Javier Bardem gives a solid and subtle performance as the beleaguered writer. Schnabel's unique directorial skills are on full display, often opting to use a handheld camera and grainy stock to give the film a documentary-like vibe, which may not be appealing to some viewers but is undeniably effective in establishing the atmosphere.

I actually disliked this movie quite a lot. Obviously Bardem does a good job in it, but so does any other actor chosen to star in a biopic - in this case it felt like a lot of other things were done as cheap tricks to make him a shoe-in for an Oscar nomination, like alternating back-and-forth from Spanish to English even in the voice over, seemingly just to show that he can. It reminded me of the pro skateboarder Paul Rodriguez, who can do the same tricks in switch stance as he can in regular but is given unearned points for doing them switch stance because that's supposed to be more difficult. It felt as though the movie was nonstop exposition as they'd have a mildly momentous scene and then go right back to explaining things. They over-relied on the narration playing over fragmented 2nd-unit shots in lieu of actually acting out the passing of time. Arenas as a writer seemed like he'd enjoy this adaptation of his life as it was indeed very artsy with the color palette and the distinct style, but for me it just didn't make for a compelling cinematic experience. Disappointing.

Very decent film but nowhere near the book!

I thought it dragged despite its fine performances.

Cuban goes all out to write...crazy true story

I guess I'm in the minority but I was surprised at how much of this focused more on Cuba than on Reinaldo Arenas' inner life or work. Though it's arguable perhaps that the two cannot be separated. And not to say the Cuban Revolution is in any way uninteresting. But I thought the movie glossed over a lot of very pivotal life moments in favor of advancing the years, which seemed backwards to me for a biopic. Either way, very well acted all around and I liked the mixture of languages even if this should have really just been in Spanish the entire time. But at least it was part of the time.

Not my type of film. Didn't really understand what was going on. It was confusing and was not particularly engaging for me.

Julian Schabel, el pintor convertido en director que nos impresionó con la magnífica "Basquiat", ahora nos vuelve a sorprender con la biografía del escritor cubano Reinaldo Arenas. La fotografía evocadora y la puesta en escena contundente sirve de lienzo para la impresionante actuación de Javier Bardem, quien logra proyectar la sexualidad, la sensibilidad y la humanidad del escritor con una visceralidad que solo lo logran los grandes actores. "Before Night Falls" es un triunfo poético.

Julian Schabel, el pintor convertido en director que nos impresionó con la magnífica "Basquiat", ahora nos vuelve a sorprender con la biografía del escritor cubano Reinaldo Arenas. La fotografía evocadora y la puesta en escena contundente sirve de lienzo para la impresionante actuación de Javier Bardem, quien logra proyectar la sexualidad, la sensibilidad y la humanidad del escritor con una visceralidad que solo lo logran los grandes actores. "Before Night Falls" es un triunfo poético.

A really wonderful surprise of a movie that I knew little going into it. Javier Bardem is great in this and it has a really wonderful style to it with wonderful direction from Julian Schnabel. Great soundtrack, cinematography, and writing as well

First of 20% of the movie is in Spanish, so as an English speaker I don't even know what's happening. I didn't like it and don't understand the high rating's, maybe it's targeted at a particular segment and they can appreciate it better. The other big stars are in guest appearance roles and basically Javier Bardem carry's the whole movie and does a great job of it but it's a waste and seems pointless as the only thing I got from the movie was that it's about a Gay writer in Cuba - that's it. The only part I enjoyed in the movie was the prison scene which must have been only 10 minutes long, waste of time.

***Due to the recent RT changes that have basically ruined my past reviews, I am mostly only giving a rating rather than a full review.***

A beautiful movie with images as poetic as the words written by Reinaldo himself, portrayed brilliantly by Javier Bardem. This has been on my very long (and almost forgotten) watch list and I can now see what all the fuss was about with Johnny Depp. With his minimal screen he managed to play two very polarising characters with such dripping sensuality he's beyond "cool"

The filmmaker has translated a poetic memoir into film. Certain adjustments were necessary - material elided or invented - but on the whole it is true to the written account. What is missing is Arenas' particular sense of humor, and also his very specific way of setting down facts - a poetry of specificity, in fact. Still, it's a serious and successful account of an important writer. Recommended to all who have an interest in poetry, the Cuban revolution, and human rights.

Biography of Cuban poet Reinaldo Arenas, this film follows his early starts then his exile from Cuba to the united states. It's very well shot by visual artist Julian Schnabel, well written & very different from most biographical films but it's an interesting film to watch.

Primeira indicação ao Oscar de Bardem.

The first stand-out biopic of the New Millennium