Two problems stand out – the script and the casting.

| Mar 8, 2022

Swank disappoints, Butler surprises.

| Original Score: 2.0/4.0 | Sep 20, 2020

Butler is rarely as adorable as he is here, as the specter of a dead man guiding his wife to new love.

| Apr 9, 2020

'P.S. I Love You' is an honest production, with characters who, assuming archetypal roles, always find moments in the script in which to move away from that position. [Full Review in Spanish]

| Sep 11, 2019

I hated every calculated second of it with a passion.

| Original Score: 0.5/4 | Jul 17, 2013

| Original Score: 3/5 | Nov 18, 2011

Full Review | Original Score: 2/5 | Nov 17, 2011

| Original Score: 2/5 | Apr 4, 2011

...a consistently watchable romantic comedy that's certainly a far cry from its underwhelming brethren...

| Original Score: 3.5/4 | Jan 30, 2010

Shmoopy or not, the movie worked for me.

| Original Score: 7/10 | Sep 8, 2008

Lisa Kudrow, the designated comic relief, has never been so consistently unfunny, and Gina Gershon looks uncomfortable in every (pseudo-)inspirational moment.

Full Review | Original Score: 1/5 | Jun 21, 2008

Hilary Swank may have two Oscars, but P.S. I Love You proves she has plenty to learn about romantic comedies.

| Original Score: 1/4 | May 12, 2008

Richard LaGravense's P.S. I Love You has plenty of sappy love-letter moments, but it's also a very touching and real-feeling look at the grieving process.

| May 10, 2008

You get the strong impression that no one involved wanted to risk being labeled "depressing," so they inserted a lot of lame comic moments into a film that doesn't need them.

| Original Score: 2/4 | May 6, 2008

May be too womanly for a guy like me, but you don't have to be either sex to know all potential is dashed in a hail of clichés...

| Original Score: 2/4 | May 6, 2008

Swank gets it just right with a fine-tuned subtle expression of confusion, despondency and rage.

| May 4, 2008

...the filmmakers mean well, but instead of a celebration of life, the whole thing seems like an extended wake.

| Original Score: 5/10 | Apr 28, 2008

It was Irish overkill. There didn't seem to be a chronological plan with the letters, so poor Holly is just forced to sit and wait to hear from her dead husband.

| Original Score: 4/10 | Mar 4, 2008

Talk about uneven. 'P.S. I Love You' is more uneven than an emery board, and every bit as grating when it misses its mark, which is more often than not.

Full Review | Original Score: 1.5/4 | Feb 9, 2008

Better than the best kiss you've ever had.

| Original Score: 8/10 | Jan 22, 2008